← Back to Thought Leadership

Case Study

A Globally Known Snack-Food Giant Balances Complex Trade-offs with the EO Decision Engine

Summary

What do you do when you can't meet demand for your most profitable product because capacity is constrained? You stop guessing and get a decision you can prove.

With River Logic's Enterprise Optimizer® (EO) Decision Engine, this snack-food giant now allocates the right demand to the right location using fewer overall hours than before. It discovered that it was more profitable to reduce material and transportation costs while increasing the number of changeovers across its nationwide network. On initial optimization runs, it found $332k in cost savings per week, plus a few million in opportunity costs from freed-up inventory. The hard savings remain unmatched by any other tool the company had been using.

Initial value with the EO Decision Engine

  • $332,000 in cost savings per week
  • Millions in additional opportunity costs found

Company Overview

This customer is one of the largest snack-food and convenience-food manufacturers in North America. It has over 20 plants, around 30 platforms, over 100 processing lines, and a few hundred packaging lines. It also serves nearly 200 destination stations, which are either retailers or distributors.

20

Plants

30

Platforms

100+

Packaging lines

100+

Processing lines

200+

Retailers and distributors

The Challenge

This U.S. snack-food giant was meeting less than 90% of demand for one of its most profitable product categories. Call it Product Family A. Two steps in the manufacturing process limited production of Product Family A:

  1. Only 35% of the raw material could ever be brought into the right shape to produce Family A products.
  2. One step in the manufacturing process had to be slowed down to further process Family A.

Before the Decision Engine, the company did what most manufacturers do: it used gut feel and 20+ spreadsheets with data from sourcing, production, finance, sales, and transportation to decide where to make which products, with no visibility into the forward-looking financial impact of those decisions.

Alongside the 20+ spreadsheets, it used:

  • A solution suite from a major ERP vendor
  • A point optimization solution
  • A well-known network design tool

The company assumed transportation costs would outweigh the benefit of producing only certain products at certain plants, so it had decided to make every product at every plant to meet demand for Product Family A.

Like more than 50% of companies today, it had limited or no ability to measure cross-functional trade-offs. In complex supply chains operating in dynamic markets, the lack of usable data blocks insight into the best courses of action. Actions aren't tied to financial impact, and companies underperform over the long run. The snack-food giant was:

  • Driving up costs
  • Unable to relieve constrained capacity
  • Failing to meet demand
  • Missing major profit opportunities

The Solution Approach

To understand how and where to make which products, the company needed two things:

  • Per-product production and distribution costs: It needed to understand, product by product, the impact of everything from raw material to distribution.
  • Forward-looking financial impacts: It needed to see the forward-looking financial impact of its operational decisions. In other words, it needed an integrated financial and operational model of its supply chain.

The company acknowledged that spreadsheets made it too hard to detect the trade-offs needed to meet its objectives.

It wanted an optimization and modeling solution that could represent its end-to-end value chain, from supplier to distribution, draw data from existing systems, and show the financial and operational impact of each trade-off. It selected River Logic. After implementing a fully validated financial and operational model in the EO Decision Engine, it could finally balance:

  • Production capability complexity
  • Demand complexity
  • Cost of goods complexity
  • Transportation variations, and more

Because every recommendation came from one validated model, the team could see why the answer was better than "make everything everywhere," not just that it was.

Impact

With the EO Decision Engine, the snack-food giant now allocates the right demand to the right location using fewer overall hours than before. It discovered that it was more profitable to reduce material and transportation costs while increasing the number of changeovers across its nationwide network. On initial optimization runs, it found $332k in cost savings per week, plus a few million in opportunity costs from freed-up inventory. The hard savings remain unmatched by any other tool the company had been using. Additional benefits:

  • Reduced transportation costs: The Decision Engine optimized trade-offs between production locations and point of sale.
  • Increased throughput rates: The engine showed that optimizing production runs and the number of changeovers increased throughput while minimizing production costs.
  • Reduced labor costs: Fewer production hours were used to fulfill more demand, lowering overall labor costs.
  • Switched to on-demand production: The company now produces to demand and understands how best to use the capacity freed up by optimizing inventory.
  • Lower overall raw material costs: The company sources optimally, considering supplier contracts, costs, geography, and more.

Moving Forward

The manufacturer plans to look at tactical sourcing (across a one- to 12-week horizon) to make sure raw materials are deployed to the right producers.

It is also considering using the same Decision Engine model for asset strategy planning (1 year out), to determine capital for new plants, equipment, and capabilities and to support the annual operations planning cycle.

About River Logic

River Logic builds the Enterprise Optimizer® (EO) Decision Engine, which turns business goals into defensible, execution-ready decisions, each with the receipt: the binding constraints behind it and a trace back to the source data. Built on 25+ years of optimization R&D, one model of the business answers questions across planning domains, from network design and capacity to product mix and capital allocation.

Schedule a demo of the EO Decision Engine.

Watch How EO Decision Engine Works

Our Customers & Partners

Merck
PwC
Accenture
Microsoft
Gurobi
Kenvue
Georgia-Pacific
Bristol Myers Squibb
Tronox
ToolsGroup
ZS
McKee Foods
Philip Morris International
Yorkshire Water
Brookes
AlixPartners
Finstock
BMA
Tengler
Transnova
Cornerstone
Tarmac
Boise
Merck
PwC
Accenture
Microsoft
Gurobi
Kenvue
Georgia-Pacific
Bristol Myers Squibb
Tronox
ToolsGroup
ZS
McKee Foods
Philip Morris International
Yorkshire Water
Brookes
AlixPartners
Finstock
BMA
Tengler
Transnova
Cornerstone
Tarmac
Boise