Company Overview
The client is one of the largest family-owned manufacturers of wood products in the United States and has been in business for over 100 years. It is a global company with several thousand employees across more than 20 countries, and it manufactures commercial, residential, and industrial housing products across a handful of product families. Product managers ran a monthly planning process in Excel, planning products at the family level for each pricing region.
In the United States, demand was fulfilled by assigning plant mills to each state based on minimum freight cost. SKU production varied widely across the two dozen plants, with some producing 10 SKUs and others more than 100. When a state's assigned plant could not meet demand, the supplemental plant was also chosen based on differential freight costs. Each plant also has different raw material costs, which are driven by seasonal factors such as timber harvests.
The company wanted to maintain growth and market share in this volatile environment, but its production constraints and other variables were too complex to quantify with Excel-based planning.
Challenge
Housing demand is driven by housing starts, seasonal changes, and other unpredictable factors. Because of this, the company could not quantify the trade-offs between demand allocation and the net freight cost of cross-shipping in a way that improved profitability. Variable capacities and shipping rates at each plant kept the company from meeting demand in the most cost-efficient way, because it had no view of the financial impact of the cross-functional trade-offs involved. "80% of corporations today rely on manual spreadsheets for their analyses, and this company was no different." Like most corporations, it could not represent the complexity of its supply chain in a way that gave a real-world, real-time view of the business.
As a manufacturer with hundreds of SKUs across several product families, the company needed an integrated business planning tool that would show optimal production distributions based on dynamic, often unpredictable inputs. Its manual system was used for demand planning within each product line and optimized processes and actions only within that unit.
The company faced these problems when trying to see trade-offs:
- Without a view of constraints across all product families, it missed opportunities to improve margins and profits for the business as a whole, rather than within one product unit.
- It could not run hundreds, let alone thousands, of what-if scenarios, which limited its insight into the best courses of action.
- It had no way to scale planning across product families.
Recognizing that spreadsheets blinded it to larger opportunities, the company sought technology that would help it meet demand more effectively. It also wanted recommended optimal scenarios for holistic future planning that would include all plants and future acquisitions.
Solution Approach
After consulting a top analyst firm, the company selected River Logic. It was the only vendor that offered cross-functional optimization, supported multiple planning horizons with one solution, and enabled rapid scenario analysis. Within three months, the EO Decision Engine was delivered to support ongoing monthly and yearly planning, built once and used for both.
For monthly planning, the company now optimizes production allocation for profit, considering shift schedules, mill production schedules, freight and production cost forecasts, and more. It runs scenarios that show the impact on mills and inventories if demand is higher or lower, and it sees how every decision affects forward-looking financial, commercial, and operational metrics and constraints.
The same Decision Engine model supports an annual planning process that looks at profitability by mill, plant, product, customer, region, and channel. This supports decisions on:
- Capacity expansion and improvement
- CAPEX
- Demand manipulation for profit optimization
- Understanding NPI impacts
Executives meet regularly to review the target, which accounts for the following complexities within and across the two dozen U.S. manufacturing plants:
- Volumes
- Downgrades
- Cross-shipping costs
- Production costs
- Raw material costs
- Throughput/hours
Today, the company has full visibility into complex trade-off decisions and can answer questions like:
- How can we capture as much of the market demand as possible?
- How do we balance the different products we produce across plants?
- When will we run out of capacity, and what should we do at that point?
- What if housing starts are higher than our forecast?
- As we get close to capacity, does our profit go down because our inventory has increased?
Impact
With the EO Decision Engine, the company can now:
- Identify the best shipping destinations from each plant so demand is met optimally.
- See recommended SKU substitutions as needed, for example substituting higher-grade products from another plant to meet demand, which protects overall profitability.
- Limit delivery methods, such as customer pick-up only, for lower-margin products, reducing the types of orders that deplete capacity.
The same model that meets demand in the most profitable way also prescribes courses of action for additional plant acquisitions, including the best time to purchase and the return on investment for each acquisition.
About River Logic
River Logic builds the Enterprise Optimizer® (EO) Decision Engine, which turns business goals into defensible, execution-ready decisions, each with the receipt: the binding constraints behind it and a trace back to the source data. Built on 25+ years of optimization R&D, one model of the business answers questions across planning domains, from network design and capacity to product mix and capital allocation.






















